Jane Mansley Fitness and Pilates
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Pilates
  • STRONG Nation
  • Contact
  • Gallery
  • Timetable
  • Testimonials

On “that claim” about obesity and cancer

22/3/2018

10 Comments

 
Cancer Research UK (CRUK) recently launched a social media campaign aimed at raising awareness that obesity is the second biggest preventable cause of cancer, after smoking. I was alarmed. I then looked at the data supporting the claim and changed my mind.

First up, it is important to realise that CRUK are only talking about preventable cancers. Fourteen factors have been identified, which are responsible for a total of 43 % of cancers in the UK. More globally, the World Health Organisation agrees that around 30-50% of cancer cases are preventable. 

This means that if you take a sample of 100 cases of cancer in the UK, on average, 43 of those cases could have been prevented were those people to have had optimal levels of the fourteen factors. 57 of those people, sadly, would have got cancer, no matter how healthy their lifestyle was, because their case was due to other factors, such as their genetics. Some slim people will be among these patients. This doesn’t mean that a slim person won't get cancer. It just explains how it is possible for overweight to be a cause of cancer, while slim people can still get cancer.

CRUK’s claim failed to make clear that the majority of cancers are not known to be preventable, and in doing so, caused some confusion, so I have addressed this by drawing up a pie chart, using the same source data as CRUK, which as well as including the fourteen lifestyle factors, also includes the other "non-lifestyle" cancer cases, for which a preventable cause hasn't been identified.
Picture
I have indicated factors which increase risk with a “-” and which reduce risk with a “+”. Source: Parkin and Walker (2011). The fraction of cancer attributable to lifestyle and environmental factors in the UK in 2010. British Journal of Cancer. 105: S77–S81.
Smoking was found to be responsible for 19.4 % of all new annual cancer cases in the UK (in 2010). That’s the big red chunk responsible for more cancers than any other preventable factor. Excess weight was responsible for a further 5.5%, the fairly sizeable orange slice of pie. But, CRUK have taken a small liberty with the data - dietary factors (suboptimal levels of fruit and veg, fibre, red meat and salt) sum to 9.2 % of cancers. By dividing them up into small slices, they have downplayed the relative importance of a healthy diet. Add insufficient exercise to the list and you are up at 10.2 %, and alcohol brings it to 14.2%. This means that diet and exercise are nearly three times as important as weight! Let’s redraw that pie chart.
Picture
I have indicated factors which increase risk with a “-” and which reduce risk with a “+”. Source: Parkin and Walker (2011). The fraction of cancer attributable to lifestyle and environmental factors in the UK in 2010. British Journal of Cancer. 105: S77–S81.
Now diet and exercise become the second most important cause of preventable cancer (green slice), while overweight is demoted to a (still important) third place. CRUK are correct only insofar as the data support healthy weight being better than overweight. However, I hope that this persuades you that the person who eats healthily, avoids alcohol and keeps active, yet struggles to keep their weight down, is statistically far less likely to get cancer than the skinny couch potato who lives on bacon washed down with gin. ​
The person who eats healthily, avoids alcohol and keeps active, yet struggles with their weight, is less likely to get cancer than the skinny couch potato living on bacon washed down with gin. 
CRUK have been accused of being judgemental about obesity. They are on a mission to educate people to empower them to make informed choices to reduce their own risk of cancer. 5.5 % may be a small fraction of the total, but that percentage relates to over 17,000 people per year in the UK. Over 17,000 individuals, each with families and friends. How could a responsible educator fail to make this point, for the sake of avoiding offence? I certainly hope that they had no ulterior motive to shame people who are overweight or obese. They do recognise that weight management is difficult in our environment, and are campaigning for changes which will help to make weight management easier, such restricting junk food advertising. 

However, given the relationship between diet, exercise and weight management, perhaps they could have promoted the more positive message, that an active lifestyle and healthy diet - lots of fibre, fruit and veg, avoiding salt, alcohol and red/processed meat - is the best thing you can do after not smoking to reduce your risk of cancer. Worrying about your weight should be a secondary concern when it comes to cancer.
Cancer Research UK run the risk of encouraging unhealthy, fad diets
By focussing on weight in their social media campaign, CRUK run the risk of encouraging unhealthy, faddy ways to lose weight, rather than sustainable, healthy choices. There is no conflict of the decision to make here, as staying active and keeping the identified dietary factors at optimal levels are consistent with advice to encourage weight management and more importantly, add up to a reduced overall risk of cancer.
10 Comments
Chacha
24/3/2018 11:15:40 am

Thank you for breaking this down into more realistic slices. With CRUK's insistence that fat = cancer, you'd almost think they'd received £10m from Slimming World, or something...

Reply
Lori
24/3/2018 03:49:09 pm

Considering they took £10mn from Slimming World with the expressed intention, clearly stated in both websites, of publicising the obesity-cancer link, I would say it’s more than fair to assume CRUK is specifically helping out the UK’s number-one weightloss company. Specifically for profit.

Reply
Lucie Colwell
26/3/2018 09:09:13 am

I need to get back to a health weight, and I'm damned if I'm giving money to Slimming World now! Lost all credibility with this "deal" as have CRUK for me, because the repulsive comments on their live feed on Facebook, were not monitored and I was personally attacked!!

Reply
Raj
29/3/2018 11:32:00 am

So obesity is a cause of preventable cancers then?

Reply
Jane Mansley
29/3/2018 12:09:30 pm

Yes it is.

Reply
Ed
31/3/2018 12:51:37 am

Diet, excercise and alcohol? Yes that is one factor.

This seems kind of desperate, considering it’s about attacking a cancer charity?

Reply
Jane Mansley
31/3/2018 10:32:50 am

Cancer Research UK do a lot of great work and have my support. My intention is solely to discuss the representation of the data in this campaign.

Reply
Addiction consulting link
18/7/2018 02:38:43 pm

If you work with a sex addiction in a treatment capacity, it can be difficult and a little awkward to know how to provide the client/patient with proper treatment while maintaining the comfort level of everyone at hand. The following advice will help you to navigate the often complex web of treating a client struggling with sex addiction.

Reply
thegrowhealth.com link
8/11/2019 12:44:11 pm

Thanks for sharing such a nice blog .keep it up the great work. i am looking thegrowhealth.com and comes to your post and found very informative.

Reply
Philip Teare
7/7/2020 08:31:12 am

I get your frustration, but you have a large fundamental flaw here. Factors overlap. It is fair to say that just as some people are of a healthy weight range yet eat plenty of fibre... there are also many who are both overweight and eat poorly. This means that a contiguous categorical pie chart is not the way to express your concern. Yes CRUK may have expressed their findings better. But so could you. And I'd be damned surprised if I've done a perfect job myself, here.

Communication is hard. Communication of complex probabilistic causal inference is very hard. Communication of emotive, complex, covariant probabilistic causal inference, without causing upset and managing to convey the message to all readers is, sadly, damn near impossible. But we should keep trying. Cancer is awful. Weight is challenging. I wish you all the best of health. x

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Fitness and Pilates instructor with a passion for science.

    Disclaimer: Any diet or health-related information shared here is not intended to diagnose, treat, or cure any condition or replace the advice of your GP/physician. Please seek any medical advice from an appropriate health care professional.

    Archives

    December 2020
    October 2020
    June 2020
    February 2020
    August 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    October 2018
    June 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Pilates
  • STRONG Nation
  • Contact
  • Gallery
  • Timetable
  • Testimonials